1. INTRODUCTION AND LEGAL FRAMEWORK
In today’s technology-driven business world, intellectual property assets are among companies’ most valuable capital. Innovations made by employees in the course of fulfilling their employment obligations or by making use of the enterprise’s resources are regulated under the “employee inventions” regime in Turkish law. The primary legislative source governing this field consists of the provisions of Articles 113 to 122 of the Industrial Property Law No. 6769 (“IPL”) which entered into force on 10 January 2017, and the Regulation on Inventions Made by Employees, Inventions Made at Higher Education Institutions and Inventions Arising from Publicly Funded Projects (“Regulation”), published in the Official Gazette on 29 September 2017. In addition, the Employee Inventions Application Guide (“Guide”) published by the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (“TürkPatent”) is one of the most important administrative guidelines setting out the procedures and principles of implementation.
This article will address the legal nature of inventions made by company employees, disclosure procedures, employers’ claims of ownership, compensation disputes and methods of resolution; it will also evaluate the recent participation of artificial intelligence agents in the inventive process in light of the landmark DABUS decision of the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof – BGH) and Turkish law.
2. DISTINCTION BETWEEN SERVICE INVENTIONS AND FREE INVENTIONS
2.1. Legal Classification and Criteria (IPL Art. 113)
Pursuant to IPL Art. 113/para. 1, a service invention is an invention made by an employee in the course of activities they are obliged to perform within an enterprise or public administration, or an invention made during the employment relationship that is largely based on the experience and work of the enterprise or public administration. All employee inventions falling outside the scope of service inventions are deemed free inventions pursuant to IPL Art. 113/para. 2.
In this regard, the legislator has established two (2) main categories for the identification of service inventions, which may be summarised as follows:
- Inventions Made in the Course of Fulfilling Duties: Inventions arising from innovation and technical development activities that the employee is directly obliged to carry out pursuant to the employment contract, job description or the employer’s specific instructions.
- Inventions Based on the Enterprise’s Experience and Work: Inventions made during the employment relationship, largely by making use of the company’s technical infrastructure, data pool, laboratory facilities or know-how, even if they are not directly within the employee’s job description.
2.2. Labour Law Context (Labour Law No. 4857 and the Duty of Loyalty)
Service inventions sit at the intersection of industrial property law and labour law norms. Under the Labour Law No. 4857 (“Labour Law”) and the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (“TCO”), the employee owes duties of loyalty and confidentiality towards the employer. In this context, it is clear that an employee’s concealment of a service invention from the employer will give rise to consequences under multiple statutes.
Indeed, an employee’s attempt to register a service invention in their own name by concealing it from the employer, or disclosing it to third parties, will not only result in patent usurpation pursuant to IPL Art. 111, but will also constitute conduct contrary to honesty and fidelity under Labour Law Art. 25/II-(e), thereby laying the grounds for the immediate termination of the employment contract for just cause.
3. INVENTION DISCLOSURE AND OWNERSHIP MECHANISM
3.1. Employee’s Disclosure Obligation and TürkPatent Employee Inventions Application Guide
Pursuant to IPL Art. 114 and Regulation Art. 5, when an employee makes a service invention, they are obliged to notify the employer in writing without delay. The principles observed by the Guide in interpreting this disclosure obligation are as follows:
- Completion of the R&D Project Need Not Be Awaited: Disclosure must be made immediately by means of an Invention Disclosure Form as soon as the technical details and solution method of the invention can be defined.
- Content of Disclosure: The disclosure must clearly set out the technical problem, the solution, the enterprise experience utilised, and, where applicable, the names and contribution ratios of other contributing employees.
- Confidentiality: Until the invention acquires the character of a free invention, it must be kept strictly confidential by the employee (IPL Art. 114/6).
In assessing whether disclosure has been made without delay pursuant to the Guide, consideration is given to whether confidentiality obligations have been breached, whether a disclosure has been made that would affect the grant of a patent or utility model, and whether another person has filed a patent application due to late disclosure. For this reason, disclosures such as articles, presentations or discussions with business partners relating to the invention should not be made prior to making the disclosure and, where necessary, signing a written confidentiality agreement.
The employer must, without delay and in writing, notify the employee of the date on which the disclosure was received and must provide the assistance necessary for the employee to make a proper disclosure. Pursuant to the Guide, the employer may broadly determine the procedures and principles of disclosure within the scope of Regulation Art. 5.
The employee is obliged to make disclosure for all service inventions made during the employment relationship. Even if the employment relationship ends after or without the making of disclosure, the employee’s obligation to make disclosure and remedy any deficiencies continues.
3.2. Employer’s Claim of Rights and Preclusive Period
First, with regard to the operation of the disclosure process, pursuant to IPL Art. 114/para. 4, the employer may, within two (2) months of the date on which the disclosure is received, request that deficiencies be remedied. In such case, the employee remedies the deficiency within one (1) month. However, if the employer makes no such request, the disclosure made by the employee is deemed valid. According to the Guide, a disclosure that is deficient or that has not been corrected within the stipulated period despite being requested is not considered a valid disclosure. In such case, the four (4)-month period for claiming rights begins from the date on which the disclosure with remedied deficiencies is received by the employer, and the employer must notify the employee in writing of this date. If the four-month period passes without action, the invention automatically becomes a free invention.
It should however be noted that, pursuant to IPL Art. 115/para. 1, the employer’s four-month period for claiming rights is of a preclusive nature. If the employer fails to make a written declaration within this period, all rights over the invention are definitively transferred to the employee and it is not possible for the employer to reclaim this right thereafter.
3.3. Consequences of Full and Partial Rights Claims
Both full and partial rights claims by the employer over service inventions may arise. Where the employer exercises a full rights claim, pursuant to IPL Art. 115/para. 2, all rights to apply for a patent and all exclusive rights over the invention are transferred to the employer. In such case, the employer is obliged to file the first application with TürkPatent; the employee, in turn, acquires the right to claim reasonable compensation and, separately therefrom, an incentive award.
The employer’s obligation to file the first application ceases to apply where the service invention acquires the character of a free invention, where the employee consents to no application being made, or where the protection of trade secrets requires that no application be filed. Where an application is not made, the potential economic losses arising from the failure to obtain a patent are taken into account in the employee’s favour in calculating compensation. If the employer who has claimed full rights fails to file the application, and also fails to do so within the period determined by the employee, the invention acquires the character of a free invention. With regard to protection in foreign countries, the employer is obliged, upon the employee’s request, to release the invention within a reasonable period that will not cause the priority period to be missed, for those countries in which the employer does not wish to obtain a patent.
Where the employer exercises a partial rights claim, pursuant to IPL Art. 115/para. 3, the invention acquires the character of a free invention; however, the employer may use the invention in its enterprise on a non-exclusive basis similar to a licence, by virtue of the partial right. We would note that, pursuant to the IPL, the employee’s departure from employment does not extinguish the rights and obligations that have already arisen in respect of the employee invention.
4. COMPENSATION AND INCENTIVE AWARD SYSTEM FOR SERVICE INVENTIONS
4.1. Incentive Award (Regulation Art. 7/2)
Where the employer claims full rights in respect of a service invention, it is obliged to pay the employee an incentive award separately from the reasonable compensation. In such case, the incentive award to be paid to the employee may not be less than the net minimum wage and must be paid to the employee within at most 2 months of TürkPatent’s formal compliance notification being served on the employer. According to the Guide, since the incentive award constitutes the consideration for the application filed in respect of the invention, no obligation to pay an incentive award arises where the invention is kept as a trade secret and no application is filed. By contrast, the reasonable compensation does not encompass the incentive award; the two payments are separate from each other.
4.2. Calculation of Compensation and Statutory Coefficient Table
Pursuant to Regulation Art. 10 et seq., the compensation to be paid to the employee is determined by the formula: Profit Derived from the Invention × Invention Group Coefficient × Contribution Share. Pursuant to the Regulation, the profit derived from the invention may be calculated by three different methods depending on whether the enterprise uses the invention itself or exploits it through licensing, sale or exchange. Pursuant to the Regulation, the coefficients are taken from the table in Art. 21/3 based on the group to which the invention belongs pursuant to Regulation Art. 20/1 and the profit bracket. Where an invention is made by more than one employee, the compensation and method of payment are determined separately for each; a sample calculation is set out in Regulation Annex 1.
The methods for calculating the profit derived from the invention in question may be listed as follows:
- Comparison Method: Based on comparable free licence agreements in the market or the net contribution of the invention to the product’s selling price.
- Enterprise Benefit Method: Based on the net positive difference between the company’s costs and revenues resulting from the use of the invention, in other words, savings and increased efficiency.
- Estimation Method: Where the first two methods cannot be applied, a hypothetical reasonable price that the employer would have paid to purchase the invention from a free inventor is assessed.
It should be noted that Regulation Art. 21/para. 2 also sets a ceiling with respect to the employer’s statutory obligation to pay compensation. Pursuant to this provision, the employer has no statutory obligation to pay compensation in respect of the portion of the profit exceeding 150,000 times the net minimum wage.
The Guide also draws attention to the following matters in practice with respect to the calculation and payment of compensation:
- Where no profit is derived from the invention, the employer has no obligation to pay compensation; in such case, the payment to be made is limited to the incentive award.
- No distinction is made between national and international profit in calculating profit; pursuant to Regulation Art. 12, the profit determined within the scope of the Corporate Tax General Communiqué (Serial No. 1) is accepted as the profit derived from the invention.
- Unless otherwise agreed, the compensation is paid in annual instalments based on the net minimum wage applicable in the period in which the profit is accounted for; where payment in periods exceeding one year has been agreed, the net minimum wage applicable in the period in which payment is to be made is used as the basis. The parties may also agree on a lump-sum, one-off payment.
- Following a claim of rights over a service invention, the employer may not evade payment of compensation by asserting that the invention is not worthy of protection; however, if an action seeking a declaration that the invention is not protectable is upheld, the employee may not claim compensation.
- If the employer wishes to abandon the patent application or the patent right before paying the compensation, it must notify the employee and, upon request, transfer the right to the employee at the employee’s expense; if the employee fails to respond within three months, the employer may abandon the patent application or the patent right. According to the Guide, terminating protection by not paying annual fees without notifying the employee does not extinguish the obligation to pay compensation.
- The Guide recommends that, for evidential purposes in the event of a dispute, a separate written agreement be executed for each invention and each inventor, setting out the contribution ratios, the invention group and the method of payment.
5. COMPENSATION DISPUTES AND METHODS OF RESOLUTION
5.1. Mandatory Rules and Prohibition on Advance Waiver
The provisions of IPL Art. 117 and Regulation Arts. 25–26 are of a mandatory nature. Within the scope of these provisions, clauses inserted in advance into employment contracts to the effect that “the employee’s invention rights and compensation receivables are included in the salary received and no separate compensation shall be paid” are absolutely void by operation of law. Accordingly, the employer cannot escape liability by means of a contractual provision stipulating in advance that no compensation will be paid in respect of employees’ prospective inventions.
Furthermore, pursuant to IPL Art. 117/para. 2, even if the compensation determined by the employer does not contravene mandatory provisions, it shall be deemed invalid if it is significantly incompatible with equity. The employee may raise their objections regarding the inequity of the compensation in writing within at most six (6) months of the termination of the employment relationship.
5.2. Mediation, Mandatory Arbitration and Judicial Recourse
If, within two (2) months of the date on which the patent or utility model is granted (where the employer has claimed full rights), or within two (2) months of the date on which the employer begins to benefit from the invention (where the employer has claimed partial rights), the employer and employee fail to agree on the compensation and method of payment, the dispute shall be resolved by way of arbitration pursuant to the Regulation. The Act and the Regulation have rendered the arbitration provisions of Art. 407 et seq. of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (“CCP”) applicable without the need for a separate arbitration clause. Prior to resorting to arbitration, the parties may take steps to resolve the dispute through mediation. However, such mediation does not constitute a mandatory step in the nature of a procedural precondition. In disputes with a foreign element, the International Arbitration Act No. 4686 applies. The same arbitration procedure also applies where the employment relationship ends prior to the grant of a patent or utility model, and in disputes between employees.
6. CONSIDERATIONS IN THE EVENT OF AN EMPLOYEE MAKING AN INVENTION WITH AN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AGENT
6.1. The Landmark DABUS Decision of the German Federal Court of Justice
Today, the direct participation of artificial intelligence agents in R&D activities as a result of the current state of technology and the increasing use of artificial intelligence arising therefrom raises the question “who is the inventor?”, which is the most fundamental pillar of patent law. At the global level, the most concrete case law on this matter was delivered by the German Federal Court of Justice on 11 June 2024 in the DABUS case.
The fundamental principles set out by the German Federal Court of Justice’s decision are as follows:
- Artificial intelligence systems (such as DABUS) cannot be named as inventors in a patent application. Patent law is human-centric; the quality of inventorship belongs exclusively to natural persons.
- Artificial intelligence is not an autonomous creator but an advanced tool that the employee makes use of in the inventive process.
- The German Federal Court of Justice held that, in an invention obtained through the use of artificial intelligence, a natural person may be and must be named as the inventor. According to the Court, a human contribution that substantially influences the overall success of the invention is sufficient to be regarded as an inventor; the nature or intensity of such contribution is not determinative. Whether owning, developing or operating an artificial intelligence system is sufficient on its own has been left open. The fact that an application contains a statement to the effect that the invention was generated by artificial intelligence alongside the natural person inventor does not require the rejection of the application.
This approach has been adopted in other important jurisdictions as well. The European Patent Office Legal Board of Appeal has held in various decisions that, pursuant to the European Patent Convention, the inventor named in the application must be a natural person with legal capacity. The United Kingdom Supreme Court, in its decision of 20 December 2023 in Thaler v Comptroller-General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks [2023] UKSC 49, found that the inventor must be a natural person under the Patents Act 1977 and that DABUS could not be named as an inventor; it specifically emphasised, however, that it was not assessing the general patentability of inventions produced by artificial intelligence.
6.2. Implications under Turkish Law
Pursuant to IPL Art. 109/1, the right to apply for a patent belongs to the inventor or their successors. Under the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, the capacity to have rights is granted exclusively to natural and legal persons, and pursuant to IPL Art. 90/5, the first and last name of the natural person inventor must be declared in the application. Accordingly, in Turkish law as well, the registration of an artificial intelligence agent as an inventor is legally impossible.
The legal consequences of an employee developing an invention using an artificial intelligence agent may be explained through practical scenarios as follows:
| Scenario & AI Contribution Level | Legal Status & Inventorship | Ownership & Compensation Regime |
|---|---|---|
| 1. AI-Assisted Invention: The employee formulates the problem, prepares the data, and uses AI as a tool for analysis and simulation. | In this case, the employee is the inventor in full. The AI is a technical tool. The human mind has guided the inventive step. | In this context, the invention will constitute a classic service invention. The employer may claim full rights. The employee receives a full share under the incentive award and the compensation table. |
| 2. Hybrid Collaboration: The AI generates numerous variants; the employee selects the technical solution, verifies it and adapts it for industrial application. | In this case, the employee is the inventor. The selection, technical verification and industrial application of the problem are based on a human contribution. | In this case, the service invention regime applies. The enterprise’s artificial intelligence infrastructure contribution is taken into account in the calculation of compensation. |
| 3. Fully Autonomous AI Output: Technical output generated autonomously by AI without any human direction. | In this case, the risk of falling outside patent protection may arise. If there is no human contribution, no inventor can be named. The application may be rejected on procedural grounds. | In this case, the invention must be protected as a Trade Secret / Know-How due to the risk of non-patentability. Furthermore, the employee’s right to compensation becomes debatable. |
6.3. Impact of the AI Tool and Company Infrastructure on Compensation Calculation
In the event that an employee makes an invention using artificial intelligence tools, the enterprise’s contribution will be determinative in the calculation of compensation. Pursuant to Regulation Art. 20/para. 2: “The enterprise’s contribution consists of the technical tool and equipment support provided to the inventor; energy, raw materials and the tools and devices of the enterprise that have contributed significantly to the realisation of the invention.” Corporate artificial intelligence models licensed by the employer, company servers and proprietary data pools will be recognised as full technical tool support from the enterprise, and the invention will be directly evaluated in the category of inventions to which the enterprise has made a full contribution.
7. CONCLUSION AND ASSESSMENT
The IPL and the relevant Regulation, while protecting the creative intellectual capital of employees, also provide companies with the assurance of obtaining a return on their R&D investments. The smooth functioning of the system depends on compliance with the deadlines for disclosure and rights claims, as well as the meticulous application of the statutory compensation schedule and incentive award rules. In the modern era in which artificial intelligence agents have become integrated into R&D processes, as confirmed in the German Federal Court of Justice’s DABUS decision, the legitimate foundation of patentability and inventorship remains human labour and the guiding human intellect. The structuring of companies’ innovation and intellectual property processes in accordance with these legal principles is of vital importance both for the protection of patent portfolios and for industrial peace.
For more detailed information, you may review our similar works addressing the intersection of artificial intelligence and labour law: “Overview of the European Union Artificial Intelligence Act and Effects on Turkish Companies” and “AI Compliance and Market Entry Guide for International Investors in Turkey“. You may access our website, where all our publications are available, here. For detailed information on service inventions, compensation disputes or artificial intelligence law, you may reach our team here.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Industrial Property Law No. 6769, Date of Adoption: 22/12/2016, Official Gazette Date: 10/01/2017, No. 29944.
Labour Law No. 4857, Date of Adoption: 22/05/2003, Official Gazette Date: 10/06/2003, No. 25134.
Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Date of Adoption: 12/01/2011, Official Gazette Date: 04/02/2011, No. 27836.
Regulation on Inventions Made by Employees, Inventions Made at Higher Education Institutions and Inventions Arising from Publicly Funded Projects, Official Gazette Date: 29/09/2017, No. 30195.
Regulation on the Working Procedures and Principles of the Re-examination and Evaluation Board of the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office, Official Gazette Date: 26/04/2017, No. 30049.
Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TÜRKPATENT), Employee Inventions Application Guide: Employee Inventions, Inventions Made at Higher Education Institutions and Inventions Arising from Publicly Funded Projects within the Scope of Industrial Property Law No. 6769, Ankara: TÜRKPATENT Publications. Version: 30.06.2020, Rev:00. Accessed: webim.turkpatent.gov.tr
World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), WIPO Overview: Intellectual Property Services, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) and Innovation Frameworks, Geneva: WIPO.
German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof – BGH), Decision Date: 11 June 2024, Case No.: Az. X ZB 5/22 (DABUS Decision – Landmark Precedent on the Inability of Artificial Intelligence Systems to be Named as Inventors and the Requirement of a Natural Person Inventor).
European Patent Office Board of Appeal (EPO BoA), DABUS Decisions (consolidated files J 0008/20 and J 0009/20).
Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TÜRKPATENT), Trademark Examination Guide, Ankara, 2021 (sections 3.2.29 and 6.2).
United Kingdom Supreme Court, Thaler v Comptroller-General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks [2023] UKSC 49, Decision Date: 20 December 2023.