Who Will Have the Customer Database When the Franchise Agreement Ends?

Contributors

همکاران

Партнер / Юрист (адвокат)

I. Legal Framework for Electronic Signatures in Turkey The main legislation regulating the legal and technical aspects of electronic signatures and the principles regarding their use in Turkey is the Electronic Signature Law No. 5070 (“ESL”), which entered into force after being published in the Official Gazette dated 23/1/2004 and numbered 25355. The purpose of the Law is to regulate the legal structure of electronic signatures, the activities of Electronic Certificate Service Providers (“ECSP”) and the usage areas of electronic signatures. In order to implement the practices in the field of electronic signature, the “Regulation on the Procedures and Principles Regarding the Implementation of the Electronic Signature Law” and the “Communiqué on the Processes and Technical Criteria Related to Electronic Signature” have been put into effect. The administrative and supervisory authority in this field is the Information and Communication Technologies Authority (“ICTA”), which is authorized to supervise the activities of ECSPs. There are also special regulations regarding electronic signatures in our basic laws: The consequences of electronic signature in Turkish law in terms of substantive and procedural law are regulated in our basic laws with an academic integrity that will complement each other. In this context,  pursuant to Article 14/II of the Turkish Code of Obligations (“TCO” ), unless there is a contrary regulation in the law, texts that can be sent and stored through a secure electronic signature meet the written form requirement; Pursuant to Article 15/I of the same law, a secure electronic signature contains all the legal consequences of a handwritten wet signature. In terms of procedural law discipline, Article 199/I of the Code of Civil Procedure (“CCP”) defines data stored electronically as legal “documents”, however, under Article 205/II of the CCP, it is clearly regulated that electronic data duly issued using a secure electronic signature will have the force of a “conclusive document”. Within the scope of the registration and operation of commercial relations, under the provisions of Article 1526 of the Turkish Commercial Code (“TCC“), electronic transactions and the exercise of the power of representation in relation to company law and negotiable instruments have been brought to a special legal framework. II. Electronic Signature, Secure Electronic Signature and Qualified Electronic Certificate Concepts 1. Electronic Signature (Simple/Standard Electronic Signature) Pursuant to Article 3/b of the ESL, an electronic signature is electronic data that is attached to another electronic data or has a logical connection with electronic data and is used for authentication purposes. This definition is a technology-independent broader concept. A name written at the end of the e-mail, a scanned wet signature image, or simple verified signatures made on foreign platforms fall within this scope; However, such signatures do not offer an absolute legal guarantee of the integrity or identification of the document. 2. Secure Electronic Signature (“SES”) Pursuant to Article 4 of the ESL, a secure electronic signature is an electronic signature that is exclusively connected to the signatory, created with a secure electronic signature creation tool that is only at the disposal of the signatory, provides identification based on a qualified electronic certificate and enables the determination of whether the signed data has been changed later. In terms of its legal consequences, it has the same legal effect as the signature made by hand. 3. Qualified Electronic Certificate (“QES”) An electronic certificate is an electronic record that links the signature verification data and identity information of the signatory. In order for a certificate to be “qualified”, in accordance with Article 9 of the ESL; It is obligatory to include the statement that the certificate is qualified, the identity information of the ECSP and the name of the country where it was established, the identity information of the signatory, signature verification data, validity period, serial number and the secure electronic signature of the ECSP. A secure electronic signature can only be created based on a valid QES obtained from an ECSP authorized by the ICTA. III. Foreign Electronic Signature Platforms (DocuSign, Adobe Sign , etc.) Working Model and Comparison Platforms like DocuSign, Adobe Sign, and HelloSign (Dropbox Sign) operate on a “Software as a Service” (SaaS) based business and revenue model. All of these platforms use similar mechanisms in terms of technical and legal infrastructure:
  • Technical Process: The user uploads the contract to the system and specifies fields such as signature/date. The system sends an access link to the other party and, if necessary, provides verification via SMS OTP (one-time password).
  • Cryptographic Encryption: A unique hash algorithm (Hash) is generated from the current state of the document as soon as the signature is made. If a subsequent change is made to the document, this encryption is broken and tampering can be detected.
  • Audit Trail: At the end of the process, a “Certificate of Completion” is created, which records the signatory’s email address, IP address, timestamp, and device information.
There is no difference in the level of validity between platforms such as DocuSign and Adobe Sign in terms of technical or Turkish law. Both platforms are subject to the ESIGN Act in the US and eIDAS regulations in the EU. However, in Turkish positive law, pursuant to Article 8/I of the ESL, it is obligatory to be an Electronic Certificate Service Provider established in Turkey and to be authorized by notifying the ICTA in order to produce a Qualified Electronic Certificate. In addition, pursuant to Article 18 of the ESR, ECSPs are obliged to create their own signature creation data and certificates within the borders of the Republic of Turkey. Since these foreign platforms  are not in the position of an ECSP that has completed its notification before the ICTA in Turkey and their certificates are not accepted and guaranteed by an authorized ECSP established in Turkey in accordance with Article 14/II of the ESL, they cannot produce a valid QES within the borders of Turkey and therefore a SES that has legal consequences equivalent to a handwritten signature within the meaning of Articles 4 and 5/I of the ESL. Pursuant to Article 14 of the ESL, in order for certificates issued by an ECSP established in a foreign country to be considered as qualified electronic certificates in Turkey, they must have international agreements or be accepted by an ECSP established in Turkey. Since these two conditions are not met for Adobe Sign and DocuSign, signatures produced through these platforms do not qualify as SES in terms of Turkish law and have the status of “simple electronic signature”. IV. The Validity of Contracts Signed Through DocuSign in Terms of Turkish Law 1. Transactions Subject to Freedom of Form (Contracts That Can Use DocuSign) Pursuant to Article 12 of the Turkish Code of Obligations, the validity of contracts does not depend on any form unless otherwise stipulated by law. Contracts that are not subject to any form of validity by law, and therefore can be concluded even orally (e.g., ordinary purchase and sale agreements, service agreements, confidentiality agreements), are considered valid under substantive law, even if they are signed through DocuSign or Adobe Sign. The use of these platforms in cross-border contracts that have foreign elements and are subject to foreign law is sufficient and valid in accordance with international standards. 2. Transactions Subject to the Ordinary Written Form Requirement (Cases Where DocuSign is Not Sufficient) Pursuant to the legislation, the use of a wet signature or secure electronic signature is required for the validity of transactions whose validity is based on “written form”  (TCO Art. 14/II and Art. 15/I). If transactions subject to ordinary written form, such as transfer of receivables, non-compete agreements, and employment contracts, are signed with DocuSign, there is a violation of the form of validity. The legal consequence of this situation is that the contract is null and void due to the lack of form in accordance with Article 12/II of the TCO. 3. Official Form, Special Ceremony and Guarantee Agreements (Transactions That Cannot Be Made Even with a Secure E-signature) Pursuant to Article 5/II of the ESL, there are exceptional transactions that cannot be carried out even with a secure electronic signature:
  • Transactions subject to official form: Transactions such as the sale of real estate, the establishment of a mortgage on real estate or an official will.
  • Transactions subject to special ceremony: Marriage or oral/handwritten will.
  • Guarantee agreements: Personal and guarantees and collateral agreements guarantee contracts such as surety and pledge, except for bank letters of guarantee and surety bonds issued by insurance companies residing in Turkey.
Since, by law, these transactions cannot be made with a secure electronic signature, making them through DocuSign is strictly subject to nullity in terms of substantive law. These transactions must be carried out in the presence of an public officer (notary, land registry officer, etc.) and with a wet signature. V. Evaluation in Terms of Proof Law in Terms of Turkish Courts
  • Secure Electronic Signature (SES): Electronic data duly created with SES are in the form of a “conclusive document” pursuant to Article 205/II of the CCP and constitute conclusive evidence until proven otherwise. In case of denial, the judge examines ex officio whether the conclusive document was created with SES (CCP Art. 205/III).
  • Simple Electronic Signature (DocuSign/Adobe Sign): Documents signed with these platforms do not have the quality of “conclusive document”, which is conclusive evidence. Within the scope of Article 199 of the CCP, they are only “documents” and are considered as “discretionary evidence” in court.
  • Beginning of Proof: If the other party denies the signature, the e-mail records and Audit Trail obtained through DocuSign can be considered as the “beginning of proof” that shows the legal transaction in question as probable in accordance with Article 202 of the CCP. If the document is considered as the beginning of proof, it becomes possible as a rule to hear witnesses in court to prove the legal transaction.
VI. Practical Advice for Implementation and Risk Analysis The risk analysis and measures to be taken regarding the use of foreign e-signature platforms in practice are as follows:
  1. Form Requirement Analysis: When designing contract processes, the legal form requirements to which the contract is subject according to its type should be analyzed in advance. In transactions subject to form,  Qualified Electronic Signature infrastructures offered by domestic ECSPs such as Kamu SM, E-Tuğra, TürkTrust, which have direct e-Government integration or are authorized by ICTA, should be preferred instead of foreign platforms.
  2. Management of Probative Risk: Since contracts established through DocuSign will not constitute conclusive evidence in case of dispute, identity verification security should be increased even in commercial contracts subject to freedom of form. In-platform SMS verification (“OTP”) and two-step verification options must be activated to strengthen the quality of the beginning of proof.
  3. Retention of the Audit Trail: The “Audit Trail” created when the contract is completed; Since it contains the IP address, verification logs and time stamp of the signatory, it should be meticulously stored in the digital archive for the applicable statutory limitation periods in order to prove the document nature and identity in the event of a dispute.
For more information about the electronic signature regime, you can contact our lawyer team.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Are contracts signed with electronic signature valid in Turkish Law?
Answer: Yes. Signatures made with a SES in accordance with the ESL have the same legal consequences as a handwritten wet signature in accordance with the Turkish Code of Obligations (Article 14/II and Article 15/I of the TCO) and fully meet the written form requirement.
Do e-signatures made with foreign platforms such as DocuSign or Adobe Sign replace wet signatures in Turkey?
Answer: No. E-signatures made through foreign platforms such as DocuSign, Adobe Sign, or HelloSign generally fall under the category of “Simple/Standard Electronic Signature” in Turkish law. They are not considered equivalent to a wet signature unless they are based on a QES obtained from an authorized ECSP in Turkey within the scope of ESL.
Can documents signed with foreign e-signature platforms be used as evidence in Turkish courts?
Answer: Yes. Pursuant to Article 199/I of the CCP, data stored electronically is a “document”. Although signatures made through foreign platforms (DocuSign, etc.) are not considered “conclusive documents” in the equivalent of wet signatures, they can be presented as discretionary evidence/document showing the declaration of will and commercial relationship between the parties in Turkish courts.
Can company representatives use e-signatures under the Turkish Commercial Code (“TCC”)?
Answer: Yes. Pursuant to the provisions of Article 1526 of the TCC, authorized representatives in transactions related to corporate law and negotiable instruments can exercise legally valid representation and signature powers electronically by using Secure Electronic Signature (SES).
What is the difference between a Secure Electronic Signature (SES) and a Simple Electronic Signature?
Answer: Simple E-Signature (Article 3/b of the ESL): These include a name typed at the end of an e-mail, a scanned wet signature image, or signatures created via foreign platforms; it does not guarantee identity and document integrity. Secure E-Signature (Article 4 of the ESL): It is a signature that is strictly at the disposal of the signatory, provides identification with a Qualified Electronic Certificate (QES), shows whether the data has been changed later, and is exactly equivalent to a wet signature. References Karabel, E. G. (2015). Written form requirement [Thesis, Marmara University]. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. (Publication No. 32712215). Erbayraktar, B. (2011). Legal Liability of the Certificate Provider to Third Parties According to the Electronic Signature and Electronic Signature Law [Master’s/PhD thesis, Istanbul University]. https://nek.istanbul.edu.tr/ekos/TEZ/48075.pdf Information and Communication Technologies Authority. (2026, January 16). Links – Electronic Signature. Information and Communication Technologies Authority. (2017, December 15). Frequently asked questions about e-signature.

Due to its unique (sui generis) structure, franchise agreements are based on the integration of franchisees, who are independent merchants, into a holistic business and marketing system developed by the franchisor. In this system, the franchisor; The brand is obliged to provide continuous support by making its know-how and ready-made business system available. On the other hand, the franchisee is responsible for operating the business on his own behalf and account by following this system and instructions exactly and paying the determined fees in return.

In today’s digital world, the concept of “customer environment” has now been replaced by the concept of “customer database”, which is an electronic network. Especially with the development of digitalization and CRM (Customer Relationship Management) systems, customer databases have become one of the most critical intangible assets of franchise agreements and one of the most valuable economic assets of commercial enterprises.

Although sharing data within the scope of cooperation between the parties while the franchise relationship continues is considered a natural process, who will have the right ownership over the customer database when the contract expires leads to serious legal disputes between the parties.

1. Legal Status of the Customer Database

To determine the fate of the database when the franchise agreement is terminated or expired, it is obligatory to first determine the legal protection regimes to which this data is subject:
  • Trade Secret Nature: Trade secret; It is information that enables a business to gain an economic advantage over its competitors, which is not disclosed to the public and cannot be accessed by third parties without effort. Customer profiles processed in the CRM system are trade secrets and their unauthorized use Turkish Trade Law ("TCC”) Pursuant to Article 55/1-d, it constitutes unfair competition.
customer-data_
  • Know-How Scope: The whole of knowledge and experience that is not protected by patents, is usually confidential and can be transferred to others is called Know-How. Customer lists that have not been disclosed to the public are essential elements of confidential Know-How, and their use by the franchisee at the end of the contract is considered unfair benefit.
  • Protection of Database Producer (FSEK): Law No. 5846 on Intellectual and Artistic Works (“FSEK”) Within the scope of Additional Article 8, a person who makes a substantial investment in the content of the database is considered a “database producer”. The producer has the right to prohibit the transfer or distribution of data to another medium for 15 years (from the date of publicity).
  • Personal Data Dimension: Any information about identified or identifiable real persons in customer lists (name, surname, TR ID number, shopping habits, etc.), Personal No. 6698 Data Protection Law (“KVKK”) Pursuant to Article 3/1-d Personal Data It is. This situation limits economic claims to fundamental human rights.

2. Fate of the Database When the Franchise Agreement Expires

Since digital data is not a physical item, no “ownership” can be claimed on them in the sense of classical property law; Entitlement is only managed through access, use and destruction protocols. In this case, if the franchise agreement is terminated, the following obligations of the parties will arise.

2.1. Franchisee’s Obligation to Return

When the contract is terminated, the franchisee is obliged to stop using all tangible and intangible goods related to the system. In this context, the franchisee; It is obliged to return the customer list and CRM records to the franchisor and delete them from its own system. This obligation is Turkish Civil Law (“TMK”) Art. 2 (Rule of Honesty) and Turkish Code of Obligations (“TCO”) It arises from the provisions of Articles 506-508 (loyalty and restitution obligation). The customer list is not allowed to be used by the franchisee for its own benefit after the contract ends. continuation or disclosure to third parties, primarily Pursuant to Article 2 of the TCC constitutes a clear violation of the principle of honesty and the obligation of loyalty after the contract. Unauthorized use of this data, which is obtained within the scope of the franchise relationship and is a trade secret, TCC will directly create unfair competition.

2.2. Equalization Fee (Portfolio Compensation)

Returning the database does not mean that the franchisee’s labor will be ignored. Although it is essentially a provision stipulated for agency agreements; Pursuant to the jurisprudence and doctrine of the Court of Cassation, Article 122 of the TCC, which is applied by analogy in the event of the termination of exclusive dealership (distributorship) and franchise agreements due to legal and economic similarities between them, regulates the institution of “equalization request” or “portfolio compensation” as it is commonly known in practice.
The main purpose of this article is to eliminate the injustice that may arise when the franchisee, who has brought a new customer circle to the parent company (franchisor) with his own efforts and investments during the contract period, is deprived of this portfolio upon the termination of the contract. Because when the contract is terminated, the franchisee loses the potential earnings from these customers; The franchisor continues to obtain economic benefits by continuing its commercial activities through this ready-made customer database it has taken over.
The legislator aimed to prevent this disproportion and unjust enrichment between the parties with the provision of Article 122 of the TCC; stipulated that the franchisee may claim equalization compensation if the following conditions are met cumulatively:

  • Thanks to the new customers brought in by the franchisee, the franchisor continues to benefit after the contract.
  • The franchisee loses the earnings from these customers because the contract expires.
  • Equity of compensation payment.

3. Evaluation and Data Security in Terms of KVKK

As a rule, the return of the customer portfolio and the related equalization requests, which come to the fore with the termination of franchise agreements, are evaluated on the axis of the law of obligations and the rule of good faith. However, the fact that the customer database subject to the dispute has the qualification of “personal data” within the scope of the KVKK directly affects the legal character of the dispute and makes the issue not a mere commercial dispute.

Although the ownership of the data in question is attributed to the franchisor in accordance with commercial practices and freedom of contract, it is not legally possible to return this data unconditionally or automatically in the face of the mandatory norms and data security principles of the KVKK. The KVKK rules, which were established to protect fundamental rights and freedoms, draw the limits of commercial contract provisions.
In this respect, the contractual refund obligation is not only commercial; It is necessary to handle it within the framework of KVKK legislation, including the obligation to inform, the requirement of explicit consent and lawful data transfer rules. Because full compliance with KVKK norms in the transfer, classification or destruction of the post-contract database is not a matter left to the discretion of the parties. It is a legal obligation subject to severe administrative and criminal sanctions.

3.1. Determination of Data Controller and Data Processor Titles in Franchise Relationship

The roles of the parties in the franchise relationship within the scope of KVKK vary according to the characteristics of the concrete case. However, when the contract expires, these statutes must be clearly determined for the data transfer and destruction processes to be carried out in accordance with the law. To make this determination that draws the limits of legal liability; It is based on certain criteria such as who determines the purposes and means of data processing, who is in control of the CRM infrastructure and who makes data security decisions.

In the light of these criteria, the status of the parties appears as follows:

  • Independent Data Controllers: If the franchisee processes customer data independently on its own behalf and account, it is also a data controller.
  • Joint Data Responsibility: In cases where joint decisions are made on the franchisor’s centralized CRM software, joint membership programs, and data processing standards, both parties have the status of joint data controllers.
  • Data Processor: It is also possible for the franchisee to have the title of “data processor” in cases where the franchisee processes personal data entirely within the framework of the franchisor’s instructions, information technology systems and operational standards.

3.2. Prevention of Data Transfer and Explicit Consent Obligation

As a rule, personal data cannot be processed or transferred without the explicit consent of the person concerned. In the event of termination of the contract, customers must be informed in advance, and their explicit consent must be obtained for the franchisee to transfer their customer data directly to the franchisor.

In order to be able to talk about a duly and valid explicit consent within the scope of the law, three basic elements must be present: i) the consent must be related to a specific subject, ii) it must be based on information (clarification), and iii) the consent must be expressed with free will. Accordingly, clear and understandable disclosure should be provided to the customer about whom, for what purpose and in what way their data will be transferred at the end of the contract. In addition, the customer’s consent to this transfer should not be made a prerequisite for the product or service to be offered to him/her (prohibition of making it conditional on service); The customer should be completely free to give or not to give consent.
Without complying with this procedure, a printed phrase such as “customer data belongs to the franchisor and will be transferred” to be added only to the franchise agreement or general membership conditions is legally invalid and cannot replace explicit consent.

3.3. Data Deletion, Retention Obligations and VERBIS

  • Destruction Obligation: Pursuant to Article 7/1 of the KVKK, if there is no explicit consent, the franchisee is obliged to permanently delete, destroy, or anonymize the data as soon as the contract ends.
  • Conflict with Retention Periods: Tax Procedure Law and the obligation to keep certain books and documents (e.g. 10 years) pursuant to the TCC is a legitimate reason pursuant to Article 5/2-ç of the KVKK. In this case, the data is not completely deleted, but is archived for legal storage purposes only, closed to active marketing and CRM activities.
  • VERBIS: Pursuant to Article 16 of the KVKK, data controllers who meet the criteria determined by the board are required to register with the Data Controllers Registry (VERBIS). In the event of termination of the contract and the actual termination of the data processing activity, it is a legal obligation for the franchisee, who is obliged to register, to update or delete the VERBIS registration.

4. Competition Law and Actual Violations

Communiqué No. 2002/2 on Block Exemption on Vertical Agreements Pursuant to Article 5, for the franchisee to benefit from the group exemption of the non-compete obligation imposed after the termination of the contract below the existence of conditions is mandatory:

  1. Limiting the prohibition to the facility, land or workplace.
  2. It is mandatory to protect the transferred know-how.
  3. Limiting the duration of the ban to a maximum of one (1) year.

Prohibitions that do not meet these conditions are subject to Law No. 4054. About the Protection of Competition Law (“RKHK”) It is deemed invalid in accordance with Article 4. On the other hand, the old dealer can take the old customer list and “We changed our brand, we are in our new place” Sending messages that can be proven by HTS records or logs creates unfair competition. However, if there is no valid non-compete policy, the dealer’s initiation of a new activity with publicly available information does not constitute unfair competition by itself (Ankara 7th ATM E. 2021/231).

The fate of the customer database in the termination of franchise agreements is a multi-layered problem at the intersection of contract law, unfair competition rules and personal data protection legislation. Within the framework of the law of obligations and the rule of good faith, the customer environment and CRM data generated during the contract should be accepted as confidential know-how and trade secrets of the franchise system and should be left to the franchisor as a rule. However, this refund obligation does not eliminate the right to equalization compensation under Article 122 of the TCC, which is the economic equivalent of the customer portfolio brought into the system by the franchisee.

On the other hand, an absolute ownership claim cannot be claimed on the parts of the database that qualify as personal data. In the absence of the prior explicit consent of the customers, the transfer of this data to the franchisor without consent is unlawful under Article 8 of the KVKK and is subject to heavy administrative sanctions. Therefore, the only way to prevent disputes is for the parties to design clarification mechanisms in accordance with the personal data legislation while the relationship is still being established and to establish a lawful return-destruction protocol by classifying the data according to its qualities at the time of termination.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Question 1: Is there an “ownership” right on the customer list in the classical sense?
Since digital data cannot be subject to physical possession, entitlement proceeds through the “access, use and destruction regime” determined by the contract.
Question 2: Should the franchisee stop using the data even if there is no clause in the contract?
Answer: Yes. In accordance with Article 2 of the TCC, the use of data must be terminated in accordance with the rule of honesty and the obligation of confidentiality after the contract.
Question 3: Can the franchisee receive compensation when the database is left to the franchisor?
Answer: Yes. If the conditions under Article 122 of the TCC are met, the franchisee may claim compensation for compensation by analogy.
Question 4: Is it sufficient to write “Data will be transferred to the franchisor” in the contract for compliance with the Personal Data Law? The contract clause cannot replace the “explicit consent” requirement of the customers arising from the law. Transfers without consent are a violation of KVKK.
Question 5: How are the legal retention periods balanced with the KVKK destruction obligation?
Answer: Documents that are required to be kept in accordance with the Tax Procedure Law or TCC are archived during the legal period, but they are completely closed to active CRM and marketing activities and made inactive.

Get Legal Support for Your Franchise Agreements and Data Security

In the termination of franchise agreements, the processes of transfer, classification, storage and liquidation of customer databases; They are extremely complex, technical and high-risk legal procedures. Managing this process with the principle of zero error, preventing possible unfair competition lawsuits and KVKK. Therefore, the support of an expert lawyer is vital to eliminate the risks of heavy administrative fines.
Protecting customer data and trade secrets in franchise systems is vital for the future of your brand. To prevent unfair use of your customer database during contract termination processes, with KVKK penalties You should work with an expert lawyer to avoid encounters and manage franchise law disputes professionally.

To get legal support in all these processes and to protect your commercial interests at the highest level, please kindly contact with our team.

Main Sources Used

Judicial Decisions

  1. Court of Cassation General Assembly of Civil Chambers, E. 2017/11-60, K. 2019/579, T. 16.05.2019.
  2. Supreme Court 19. Civil Chamber, E. 2001/819, K. 2001/4917, T. 25.06.2001.
  3. Supreme Court 11. Civil Chamber, E. 2015/1789, K. 2015/6904, Date: 14.05.2015.
  4. Supreme Court 11. Civil Chamber, E. 2018/5206, K. 2019/6934, T. 06.11.2019.
  5. Supreme Court 11. Civil Chamber, E. 2016/10011, K. 2018/3093, T. 25.04.2018.
  6. Supreme Court 11. Civil Chamber, E. 2015/12097, K. 2015/10838, T. 21.10.2015.
  7. Supreme Court 11. Civil Chamber, E. 2008/13569, K. 2010/8571, T. 22.07.2010.
  8. Istanbul 18. Commercial Court of First Instance, E. 2022/526, K. 2023/901, T. 11.12.2023.
  9. Istanbul Anadolu 10. Commercial Court of First Instance, E. 2021/500, K. 2025/397, T. 06.05.2025.
  10. Ankara Regional Court of Justice 20. Civil Chamber, E. 2023/1962, K. 2025/2279, T. 28.11.2025.
  11. Ankara 7. Commercial Court of First Instance, E. 2021/231, K. 2024/327, T. 13.05.2024.
  12. Ankara 4. Commercial Court of First Instance, E. 2023/314, K. 2024/562, T. 19.07.2024.